Effect of Bioactive B12 in Adhering Discs on Aphthous Ulcers
Jeffrey A. Burgess, DDS, MSD; Jeff T. Haley, BA, BS, JD
Commentary by Howard E. Strassler, DMD
Recurrent aphthous ulcers (RAU), colloquially called canker sores, are one of the most common inflammatory conditions of the oral mucosa, affecting approximately 20% of the US population.1 RAU is a common mucosal condition that consists of recurrent episodes of one or several rounded, shallow, painful oral ulcers at intervals of a few months to a few days with three typical presentations: (1) minor; (2) major; or (3) minor clusters (often called “herpetiform” but not related to clustered herpes ulcers).2 Minor RAU is by far the most common presentation and manifests as round, clearly defined, small painful ulcers with shallow necrotic centers, raised margins and erythematous halos.3 They are localized most commonly to the unattached oral epithelium, specifically the buccal and labial mucosa, floor of the mouth, and edge of the tongue. The lesions typically heal within 10 to 14 days without scarring.3,4 In those individuals with recurring overlapping lesions, however, the problem can be quite troublesome. Most researchers who have attempt- ed to estimate the occurrence of RAU conclude that about 20% of the US population suffers from the condition with sufficient severity to consult a physician, dentist, or pharmacist for treatment. Epidemiologic studies vary by region and the type of study cohort examined. Nonetheless, they suggest that the prevalence of RAU in the United States is between 5% and 60%.5 Population studies in various countries have found from 1.9% to 20% in the general population.3 Women are over-represented6 and whites are three times more likely to be affected than black people.7 Most estimates fall between 5% and 25%.1,3-5
Lesions associated with recurrent aphthous stomatitis (RAS) are differentiated from RAS-like oral lesions arising from systemic abnormalities such as HIV infection, autoimmune disease (eg, lupus), food allergy (eg, gluten sensitivity), Crohn’s disease, drug insensitivity, pharyngitis, and cyclic neutropenia.2,4,8-10 For uncomplicated RAS, precipitating factors include genetic predisposition, local trauma, stress, and nutritional deficiencies.2,3,11 Current treatments for RAS, regardless of etiology, include antimicrobial mouthwashes and local anesthetics which have not been shown to alter the recurrence or remission rates of sores,2,3,11 adhering dissolving discs that time release Glycyrrhiza extract (CankerMelts ®—Orahealth)12 and barrier cyanoacrylate formulations (Orabase® Sooth-N-Seal—Colgate Oral Pharmaceuticals)13 which have supportive research, and a variety of other over-the-counter (OTC) products that have not been adequately studied for efficacy.14 When OTC treatments are ineffective, topical and systemic steroids or thalidomide are often used. However, the costs, side effects, and toxicity of such treatments are often prohibitive.2,3,11 Laser ablation can provide short-term symptomatic relief and ulcer healing15 but is of very limited practical benefit.16
There is considerable literature suggesting that uncomplicated RAS may be associated with hematinic deficiency, specifically a deficiency in folic acid and vitamin B12. In a recent controlled study of 143 patients experiencing recurrent aphthous stomatitis compared with 143 age- and gender-matched patients, 26.6% of aphthous subjects demonstrated B12 deficiency in contrast to 12.6% of the controls.17 In another study, vitamin B12 levels were assessed in 35 patients with recurrent aphthous ulceration and 26 healthy controls. B12 levels were found to be significantly lower in the RAS subjects than in the controls, while significant differences were not found for the other assessed hematological factors.18 These studies, coupled with numerous other references,5,9,10,19 highlight the general assumption that vitamin B12 plays a role in the etiology of some cases of recurrent aphthous stomatitis.
Given that B12 deficiency may be the cause of ulcers in a subset of the population experiencing the condition, replacement therapy has been recommended.5 However, a number of studies suggest that the type of replacement therapy (eg, ingestion or injection) is a significant confounder of treatment outcome. For example, in a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled study reported by Kolseth, Herlofson, and Pedersen involving LongoVital® (Pharmavita, Ltd, London, UK), an herbal-based ingested tablet enriched with vitamins (including B12) and other trace elements, no difference was found between the herbal and placebo groups in terms of treatment outcome.20 In an additional double-blind, stratified-randomized clinical case-control study performed over 6 months, no significant difference in treatment outcome was found between placebo patients and those using ingested replacement therapy based on a 50% reduction in the number of ulcers and days in pain—considered by the authors as clinically relevant.20 Conversely, in a case study involving three subjects with aphthous, two of whom were deficient in B12 and one with only marginal deficiency, it was found that injected doses (vs B12 taken by ingestion) of high levels of cyanocobalamin seemed to reduce the incidence of ulcers.21 No published studies, to date, have attempted to assess the effectiveness of topical delivery of vitamin B12 to the mucosal tissues or assess the commercially available bioactive form of B12, methylcobalamin, for palliative or preventive treatment of recurrent aphthous ulcers.
Deoxyadenosylcobalamin is the main vitamin B12 analogue found in a normal diet.22 The form of B12 that is currently available in manufactured tablet form is cyanocobalamin. This latter compound (which is light stabilized by combining cobalamin with a cyano group) is not usable by the body until it has been converted in the liver or serum to a form that is bioactive, such as methylcobalamin or deoxyadenosylcobalamin.
Methylcobalamin and hydroxocobalamin have been shown to have effects on a number of conditions including peripheral neuropathy,23-25 allergy,26 and methylmalonic acidemia and homocystinuria.11 There is also evidence that methylcobalamin may affect immune function27,28 and may alter cellular function in other ways as well. For example, methylcobalamin decreases mRNA levels of androgen-induced growth factor in androgen- dependent Shionogi carcinoma.29 It has also been shown to attenuate the hypoxia/hypoglycemia or glutamate-induced reduction in hippocampal fiber spikes in vitro.30 In an animal study assessing the effect of methylcobalamin on peripheral nerve structure, doses of 500 mcg/kg were delivered to diabetic rats for 16 weeks, with subsequent comparison of isolated nerves (from diabetic and nondiabetic animals) suggesting that methylcobalamin protected myelinated nerve density as well as fiber and axon size.31 Homocysteine (tHcy) concentrations (which have been linked to atherosclerosis) are also reduced by administration of methylcobalamin.32 Hydroxocobalamin attenuates effects of toxins.33 For treatment of some diseases, hydroxocobalamin is effective where common vitamin B12 (cyanocobalamin) is not.11
Double–Blinded, Placebo–Controlled Trial
To assess the potential effect on RAS of bioactive methylcobalamin delivered once a day into the saliva, a randomized clinical trial (RCT) study was designed with a delivery vehicle that incorporated 500 mcg of methylcobalamin into a fully dissolving adhering disc (from Orahealth Corp, Bellevue, WA). From previous experimentation, it had been established that once placed in the mouth, the disc dissolved over 20 to 40 minutes. The disc ingredients, to which bioactive B12 was added, consist of food polymers (hydrophilic gums), and xylitol for flavor. This formulation (with the bioactive B12) was compared with a similar disc that contained only added food coloring.
Subjects were recruited with self-reported RAU who acknowledged having at least one lesion per month, absence of any known disease causing the ulceration, and who stated that they were not taking B12 by injection or vestibular place-ment. The initial study involved 15 subjects, seven of whom received discs with 500 mcg methylcobalamin and eight who received the placebo discs. They were given 30 discs with instructions to use two initially and then one each succeeding day, placing it near an ulcer when present. All were instructed to make careful observations of their ulcers and report their observations at least once each week over a 30-day period. Because of the limited number of subjects, statistical analysis of the data could not be done. However, descriptive statistics were strongly suggestive that the use of a disc with bioactive B12 could alter the course of the condition.
To summarize the data, two out of eight subjects (25%) who received the placebo disc reported a benefit, two out of eight were unsure, and four out of eight (50%) were confident they experienced no benefit. Of the seven subjects who received the active discs, all seven (100%) reported a benefit. Six out of seven reported reduced duration of each ulcer, four out of seven reported less peak pain from each ulcer, and four out of seven reported lower frequencies of ulcers. This initial data suggested that the discs might reduce frequency of minor RAU and reduce duration and peak pain levels of ulcers.
Given the above results, the RTC was extended to include more subjects. The disc size was reduced to improve convenience of adhering the disc to a tooth and the adhesive gum was changed from protein-based to vegetable-based to make a better-looking product (Avamin® Melts®).
Data was collected from 19 more active subjects (for a total of 26) and from 12 more placebo subjects (for a total of 20). In the active group, 20 of 26 (77%) reported improvement while only 9 of 20 (45%) in the placebo reported a perceived benefit (Chi 4.55, P < .03). Perceived pain reduction was also significantly different between groups (Chi 4.82, P < .02) with the active group reporting less pain. Although more active than placebo subjects reported reduced frequency and duration, the differences were not significant with this number of subjects. A potential interaction between disc type and outcome was suggested by the analysis.
Non–Blinded A–B–A Trial
In an A-B-A non-blinded trial, sixteen subjects were given active discs with 500 mcg methylcobalamin. (One subject also participated in part 1 above. The subject had placebo discs in the double-blind study and gave all negative evaluations. The subject then tested the active discs unblinded and gave all positive evaluations.) The subjects in this study were similarly instructed to make careful observations of their ulcers and report their observations at least once each week. From reports of new ulcers starting within a few days after use of the discs commenced, it appears that approximately 3 to 7 days of daily use was required for the preventive effects to reach full strength. When the discs were used up, each subject was queried with the same questions as used in the previously described study.
In this non-blinded study, all sixteen of the subjects (100%) reported a benefit from disc use. Twelve out of fifteen (73%) reported reduced frequency of ulcers (1 no and 3 not sure). Three subjects reported that their frequency of ulcers was reduced to zero, leaving 13 who reported that they still had at least one ulcer. Of these 13, 11 reported reduced pain from each ulcer (85%) (1 not sure, one no answer) and 11 reported reduced duration of each ulcer (85%) (2 reported no reduction). Five of the subjects who stopped using the discs at the end of the study were further questioned and reported subsequent ulcers occurring within 4 to 7 days (mean = 4.8) with a pain level as pronounced as that which occurred initially. This corresponds well with the less quantifiable observations of number of days of use required for the benefit to reach full strength. Seven subjects concluded that the active disc reduced the frequency of ulcer incidence, with two (22%) concluding that it did not.
No adverse reactions or complications were reported by subjects in this study or the prior studies.
The above studies suggest that once-a-day topical delivery in the mouth of 500 mcg of methylcobalamin (bioactive vitamin B12) is effective in reducing painful, minor recurrent aphthous ulcers. Perceived improvement is also significant. Although more active than placebo patients reported improvement in lesion duration and less frequent ulcers, the values were not statistically significant with this number of subjects. The descriptive data, however, suggests that there was perceived benefit with respect to the duration of the lesions and how frequently they were occurring in those using methylcobalamin B12. Further, the data indicates that between 2 to 5 days of everyday use is required to achieve the full therapeutic benefit of disc use, with the data also suggesting that perceived benefit persists for about 3 to 7 days after disc use is discontinued.
The mechanism by which bioactive B12 reduces pain and increases perceived improvement is not evident. A number of molecular and cellular mechanisms are possibly responsible for its therapeutic efficacy. Given placement in the mouth, absorption may occur through the mucosa as a surface effect but also through the intestinal epithelium secondary to swallowing. Direct topical effects may include enhanced peripheral nerve regeneration, localized neutrophil activation, an interaction with resident surface bacteria, or a combination of all of these effects. Systemic effects may include central nervous system activity (with psychological and physiological effects) and increased B12 levels in cases of marginal or frank deficiency.
At this point we do not know whether a lesser dose of methylcobalamin would have been as effective as that provided. Further, these studies have not helped to define the upper dose that could have therapeutic benefit. However, given that there appears to be no upper safe limit for the use of methylcobalamin, the only drawback to using a higher dose than 500 mcg is cost.
If a dose is missed on one, two, or three days, it is not clear whether extra doses should be taken to make up for the missed doses or whether, when preventive treatment is initiated, one should subsequently commence with higher than normal doses. However, based on the above research, a reasonable use estimate is that when a person first starts using the discs, he or she should use three discs the first day to quickly boost the level of methylcobalamin in the mouth surface tissue cells. When a day is missed, it appears reasonable for a person to take two discs the next day. Given absence of data suggesting risk associated with upper levels of B12, it would also appear reasonable for a person missing two or more days to use three discs the first day that treatment is subsequently resumed.
In conclusion, the above studies support the use of methylcobalamin, (Avamin® Melts®) in the management of uncomplicated recurrent aphthous ulceration.
Recurrent aphthous stomatitis (RAS) or recurrent aphthous ulcers (RAU) is a common condition, restricted to the mouth, that typically starts in childhood or adolescence as recurrent small, round, or ovoid ulcers with circumscribed margins, erythematous haloes, and yellow or gray floors. A positive family history of similar ulcers is common. This condition continues into adulthood. Our patients are relieved that the diagnosis of these uncomfortable oral ulcers is not cancer. The fact that these lesions recur and are uncomfortable creates the clinical challenge of providing our patients with a definitive treatment to relieve the symptoms over the 10 to 14 days that they exist. This paper provides an excellent overview of RAU with a focus on diagnosis and the current state-on-the-art in treatment. Also, this well-designed clinical research study provides another treatment that is easy for a patient to follow to provide relief. The data and analysis of data from these studies support the use of methylcobalamin (Avamin®Melts®, Orahealth Corp, Bellevue,WA) in the management of uncomplicated recurrent aphthous ulceration.
1. National Institutes of Health, National Institute of Dental and Craniofacial Research, NIH Publication No. 92-247, Revised July 1992.
2. Porter SR, Scully C, Pederson A. Recurrent aphthous stomatitis. Crit Rev Oral Biol Med. 1998;9(3): 306-321.
3. Ship JA, Chavez EM, Doerr PA, et al. Recurrent aphthous stomatitis. Quintessence Int. 2000;31(2): 95-112.
4. Ship II. Epidemiologic aspects of recurrent aphthous ulcerations. Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol. 1972;33(3):400-406.
5. Jurge S, Kuffer R, Scully C, et al. Mucosal disease series. Number VI. Recurrent aphthous stomatitis. Oral Dis. 2006; 12(1):1-21.
6. Kovac-Kovacic M, Skaleric U. The prevalence of oral mucosal lesions in a population in Ljubljana, Slovenia. J Oral Pathol Med. 2000;29(7):331-335.
7. Kleinman DV, Swango PA, Pindborg JJ. Epidemiology of oral mucosal lesions in United States schoolchildren. Community Dent Oral Epidemiol. 1986;22(4): 243-253.
8. Rogers RS 3rd. Recurrent aphthous stomatitis: clinical characteristics and associated systemic disorders. Semin Cutan Med Surg. 1997;16(4):278-283.
9. Scully C. Aphthous ulcers. 2007. Available at: https://www.emedicine.com/ent/topic700.htm. Accessed Aug 13, 2008.
10. Scully C, Gorsky M, Lozada-Nur F. The diagnosis and management of recurrent aphthous stomatitis: a consensus approach. J Am Dent Assoc. 2003;134(2): 200-207.
11. Andersson HC, Shapira E. Biochemical and clinical response to hydroxocobalamin versus cyanocobalamin treatment in patients with methylmalonic acidemia and homocystinuria (cblC). J Pediatr. 1998;132(1):121-124.
12. Martin M, Burgess J, Haley J. CankerMelts oral patches with licorice extract reduce pain and speed resolution of canker sores. JAPhA. 2007;47(2): 251.
13. Kutcher M, Ludlow J, Samuelson A, et al. Evaluation of a bioadhesive device for the management of aphthous ulcers. J Am Dent Assoc. 2001;132(3): 368-376.
14. Carpenter WM, Silverman S. Over-the-counter products for oral ulcerations. J Calif Dent Assoc. 1998;26(3): 199-201.
15. Convissar RA, Massoumi-Sourey M. Recurrent aphthous ulcers: etiology and laser ablation. Gen Dent. 1992;40(6):512-515.
16. Howell RM, Cohen DM, Powell GL, et al. The use of low energy laser therapy to treat aphthous ulcers. Ann Dent. 1988; 47(2):16-18.
17. Burgan SZ, Sawair FA, Amarin ZO. Hematologic status in patients with recurrent aphthous stomatitis in Jordan. Saudi Med J. 2006;27(3):381-384.
18. Piskin S, Sayan C, Durukan N, et al. Serum iron, ferritin, folic acid, and vitamin B12 levels in recurrent aphthous stomatitis. J Eur Acad Dermatol Venereol. 2002;16(1):66-67.
19. Koybasi S, Parlak AH, Serin E, et al. Recurrent aphthous stomatitis: investigation of possible etiologic factors. Am J Otolaryngol. 2006;27(4):229-232.
20. Kolseth I, Herlofson BB, Pedersen A. Norwegian LongoVital and recurrent aphthous ulceration: a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled study. Oral Dis. 2005;11(6):374-378.
21. Volkov I, Rudoy I, Abu-Rabia U, et al. Case report: Recurrent aphthous stomatitis responds to vitamin B12 treatment. Can Fam Physician. 2005;51: 844-845.
22. Chanarin I. Absorption of cobalamins. J Clin Path. 1971; 24(5):60-65.
23. Head KA. Peripheral neuropathy: pathogenic mechanisms and alternative therapies. Altern Med Rev. 2000;11(4):294-329.
24. Sun Y, Lai MS, Lu CJ. Effectiveness of vitamin B12 on diabetic neuropathy: systematic review of clinical controlled trials. Acta Neurol Taiwan. 2005;14(2):48-54.
25. Yaqub BA, Siddique A, Sulimani R. Effects of methylcobalamin on diabetic neuropathy. Clin Neurol Neurosurg. 1992; 94(2):105-111.
26. Funada U, Wada M, Kawata T, et al. Effect of cobalamin on the allergic response in mice. Biosci Biotechnol Biochem. 2000;64(10):2053-2058.
27. Tamura J, Kubota K, Murakami H, et al. Immunomodulation by vitamin B12: augmentation of CD8+ T lymphocytes and natural killer (NK) cell activity in vitamin B12-deficient patients by methyl-B12 treatment. Clin Exp Immunol. 1999; 116(1):28-32.
28. Wada M, Kawata T, Yamada K, et al. Serum C3 content in vitamin B(12)-deficient rats. Int J Vitam Nutr Res. 1998;68 (2):94-97.
29. Nishizawa Y, Yamamoto T, Tanigaki Y, et al. Methylcobalamin decreases mRNA levels of androgen-induced growth factor in androgen-dependent Shionogi carcinoma 115 cells. Nutr Cancer. 1999;35(2):195-201.
30. Yamamoto Y, Shibata S, Hara C, et al. Methylcobalamin attenuates the hypoxia/hypoglycemia- or glutamate-induced reduction in hippocampal fiber spikes in vitro. Eur J Pharmacol. 1995;281(3): 335-340.
31. Yagihashi S, Tokui A, Kashiwamura H, et al. In vivo effect of methylcobalamin on the peripheral nerve structure in streptozotocin diabetic rats. Horm Metab Res. 1982; 14(1):10-13.
32. Yazaki Y, Chow G, Mattie M. A single-center, double-blinded, randomized controlled study to evaluate the relative efficacy of sublingual and oral vitamin B-complex administration in reducing total serum homocysteine levels. J Altern Complement Med. 2006;12(9):881-885.
33. Greenberg SS, Xie J, Zatarain JM, et al. Hydroxocobalamin (vitamin B12a) prevents and reverses endotoxin-induced hypotension and mortality in rodents: role of nitric oxide. J Pharmacol Exp Ther. 1995;273(1):257-265.
About the Authors
Howard E. Strassler, DMD
Professor and Director of Operative Dentistry
Department of Endodontics, Prosthodontics and Operative Dentistry
University of Maryland Dental School
Jeffrey A. Burgess, DDS, MSD
Oral Care Research Associates
Jeff T. Haley, BA, BS, JD