Mastering the Occlusal Plane
Udo Plaster and Zirkonzahn’s PlaneSystem® offers laboratory technicians the third dimension in patient analysis
By Udo Plaster, MDT
In clinical practice, incorrectly inclined occlusal planes and functionally inadequate restorations are a common scourge. A possible reason is the (often imprecise) analysis of patient information. In an effort to make this process less prone to error, the author has developed a novel transfer approach, the PlaneSystem®. It determines the occlusal plane and any associated asymmetries individually for each patient based on the ala-tragus plane and natural head posture (NHP), and transmits the real position to the CAD/CAM system. This allows possible compensations to be detected prior to developing a treatment plan for laboratory or chairside restorations, minimizing or completely eliminating any sources of error, particularly during data transfer, that might otherwise occur when planning or fabricating a dental restoration.
Scientific studies, eg Xie et al,1 have identified the connecting line from the lower edge of the nasal wing to the center of the tragus, the so-called ala-tragus line, to be a more reliable reference for the occlusion line than Camper’s plane or the Frankfurt horizontal plane. A second important point of reference within the author’s method of transfer is the natural head posture (NHP). A 5-year study by Cooke2 and a 15-year study by Peng3 have shown that patients’ natural head posture varies by only one to two degrees when looking directly into his or her own eyes as they stand upright in front of a mirror. The NHP is related to a patient-independent reference frame that allows patient-specific variations in spatial orientation to be reproduced, a feat made possible by the PlaneSystem® developed in cooperation with Zirkonzahn.
The PlaneSystem® consists of the PlaneFinder®, the PS1-3D real and virtual articulator, the PlanePositioner® and the special CAD-PlaneTool PS1-3D software (Figure 1). It is 100% compatible with the digital workflow of the Zirkonzahn CAD/CAM system, eg the 5-TEC CAD/CAM system (Figure 2). The PlaneFinder® detects not only the NHP but also the inclination from the registered position, i.e. the zero-degree line (occlusal line angle). The models are positioned in the PS1-3D articulator using the PlanePositioner® based on the angle identified. The PS1-3D articulator was designed with special geometries to simulate patient-specific rotating, sliding and closing movements of the jaw as they occur during mastication.
Step 1. First, align the PlaneFinder® parallel to the ground.
Step 2. The mirror is set at eye-level and the height is adjusted (Figure 3). By putting her index fingers on the support device the patient is stable and is able to look in the mirror with a relaxed lower jaw position (Figure 4).
Step 3. The orientation angle is set to 90º, thus checking the position and its reproducibility. The lateral orientation angles must be set at the level of the ear canal entrance/tragus/zygomatic arch. The patient stabilizes again by means of the index fingers and has her lower jaw slightly open. Two points are marked on the patient´s skin parallel to the horizontal lines, preferably on areas that cannot be modified by the mimetic muscles (Figure 5).
Step 4. Checking the position. The patient may leave this position and walk back and forth for a while. Then she returns to the position. This may be repeated several times in order to preclude coincidences.
Step 5. Positioning through PlaneTray®. Level and height are assumed and adjusted by the PlaneTray®. The patient leans her incisors on the tray, looks in the mirror, and stabilizes with her index fingers. This position is fixed on the tray by means of registration material and without having moved the patient (Figure 6).
Step 7. A point for the swath is marked at the bottom edge of the nostrils and on the center of the tragus. According to the skeletal class the tragus point may vary (upper/lower margin). The lateral orientation angles have a scale where the angles can be read. The swath is set parallel to these points and the degrees are determined. The process of occlusion (which can be descending or ascending) is determined for the registered position. The angle may be modified on the adjustable PlanePositioner® (Figure 10).
Step 8. For an uninterrupted digital workflow, the data received and the corresponding coordinates in three-dimensional space must be correctly matched. This can be done with the S600 ARTI structured-light optical scanner and the virtual articulator implemented in the Zirkonzahn modelling software. The scanner acquires data from PS1-3D articulator, both of the models and of the articulator itself, and transfers the data directly to the software’s virtual articulator.
Step 9. The next step is the actual design step (Figure 11 and Figure 12). Ideally, the physiognomy of the patient is taken into account during this step. This is made possible by the Face Hunter 3D facial scanner, which basically works like a camera—one click will digitize a face within three-tenths of a second and create a photo-realistic 3D representation. In combination with the CAD/CAM Reality Mode module, the software generates a very good, photo-realistic representation of the virtual restoration. Since most people tend to be “visual types,” a visualization of the final restoration based on the actual patient situation allows for much more reliable planning in the interest of all parties involved and thus provides a solid foundation for high-quality restorations.
1. Xie J, Zhao Y, Chao Y, Luo W. A cephalometric study on determining the orientation of occlusal plane. Hua Xi Yi Ke Da Xue Xue Bao. 1993;24(4):422-425.
2. Cooke MS. Five-year reproducibility of natural head posture: a longitudinal study. Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop. 1990;97(6):487-494.
3. Peng L, Cooke MS. Fifteen-year reproducibility of natural head posture: a longitudinal study. Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop. 1999;116(1):82-85.
About the Author
Udo Plaster is a German master dental technician from Nuremberg, Bavaria
For more information, contact:
Disclaimer: The preceding material was provided by the manufacturer. The statements and opinions contained therein are solely those of the manufacturer and not of the editors, publisher, or the Editorial Board of Inside Dental Technology.